ScoreCard Research

The #SaveYourInternet fight against Article 17 [ex Art. 13] continues

NEW OVERHAUL GRAN SPORT PEDALS+ CAMPAGNOLO NOS DUST CAPS+RECORD TOE CLIP BOLTS
NEW Panaracer Pandura 27.5x2.4 tubeless Mountain tire
New Pillar Hex 10 internal hidden nipples aluminum 50 pieces w INSsizeTION TOOL
#SaveYourInternet - #DeleteArt13: Article 13 is About Filters!
NEW prAna Women's Roxanne Printed Capris Yoga Fitness Size XL 69 Retail
NEW Proline 200 gram Thinsulate Insulated Khaki Chest Fishing Waders w Boots
#SaveYourInternet - #DeleteArt13: Big Businesses Fighting Each Other to the Detriment of Freedom
New Promax RC-482 Mechanical Dual Pivot Front Caliper Brake 47-60 Reach
New Punch Mitts Curved PU Leather Mitts, Pair Of 2 Enjoy To Use, Free Shipping.
NEW Race Face Atlas Riser Handlebar 31.8 x 785mm 1 2 Rise Red
New Race Face Turbine CINCH Crankset, 175mm, 30t, 30mm Spindle, raceface 68 73

Article 17 [ex Art. 13]  only benefits big businesses

NEW REDLINE FLIGHT BMX 3-piece 180mm CRANKS

Due to the collateral damage created by the vague and overly broad wording of Article 17 [ex Art. 13], only big platforms and powerful rightholders will benefit from its adoption, to the detriment of all other stakeholders. 

Bad for Users

Users will have access to less content and will be unable to share their content with others, even when it’s legal. Moreover, any complaint mechanisms will be easily bypassed if blocking is done under the pretense of a terms and conditions violation, rather than as a result of a specific copyright claim.

NEW Renthal FatBar Carbon Handlebar 30mm Rise 800mm Width 35mm Clamp Carbon
NEW Rip Curl Men's Classic 2 2 Shorty Spring Wetsuit Medium

Bad for Creators

If platforms become directly liable for user uploaded content they will arbitrarily remove content based on their terms and conditions. As a result, many creators will see their content get blocked too. And, as less platforms survive the burden of this provision, creators will have less choice on where to share their creations.

Bad for competition

Only platforms with deep pockets will be able to comply with the Article 13 requirements and even if small enterprises get an exemption from its scope, this simply means they are not allowed to scale up and compete with the big US platforms, under the motto ‘in Europe, small is beautiful’!

By requiring Internet platforms to perform automatic filtering all of the content that their users upload, Article 13 takes an unprecedented step towards the transformation of the Internet from an open platform for sharing and innovation, into a tool for the automated surveillance and control of its users. (…) we cannot support Article 13, which would mandate Internet platforms to embed an automated infrastructure for monitoring and censorship deep into their networks. For the sake of the Internet’s future, we urge you to vote for the deletion of this proposal.

+70 Internet and computing luminaries Open letter

Although the latest proposed versions of Article 13 do not explicitly refer to upload filters and other content recognition technologies, it couches the obligation to prevent the availability of copyright protected works in vague terms, such as demonstrating ‘best efforts’ and taking ‘effective and proportionate measures.’ (…) I am concerned that the restriction of user-generated content before its publication subjects users to restrictions on freedom of expression without prior judicial review of the legality, necessity and proportionality of such restrictions. Exacerbating these concerns is the reality that content filtering technologies are not equipped to perform context-sensitive interpretations of the valid scope of limitations and exceptions to copyright, such as fair comment or reporting, teaching, criticism, satire and parody.

David Kaye New Maxxis High Roller II 27.5 x 3.00 Tire 120tpi Triple Compound EXO Casing

I think that the overfiltering problem is huge and the norms are so vague. Article 13 is doomed to failure. The Digital Single Market Directive draft is some speculation that if we put these really strict rules in place, all the tech companies and platforms that can afford to license content will do that. I think that’s naive.

Professor Pamela Samuelson New Maxxis High Roller II 29x2.30 Tire 120tpi 3C Maxx Terra Compound Double

The lesson, for me, is: Don’t tear down the building, be the landlord. It’s far more beneficial for me to embrace the community that is remixing my art, to set my own rules about how my work is used, and to embrace the shared creativity and profits that come from it. It wasn’t easy for me to adapt my thinking, but today I work with a number of online services to give fans what they want while still getting paid.

Wyclef Jean Grammy-award winning musician and founding member of hip-hop group The Fugees

The concern of the vzbv: Out of fear of completely unclear liability rules many contents will disappear in the net. Dubious content, so-called fake news, on the other hand, will find it even easier to spread on the internet in the future.

Klaus Müller NEW Maxxis High Roller II DC EXO TR 27.5x2.3 tubeless Mountain tire

Article 13 of the proposal on Copyright in the Digital Single Market include obligations on internet companies that would be impossible to respect without the imposition of excessive restrictions on citizens’ fundamental rights. (…) Article 13 appears to provoke such legal uncertainty that online services will have no other option than to monitor, filter and block EU citizens’ communications if they are to have any chance of staying in business.

+50 NGOs representing human rights and media freedom Open Letter

Claim: The Internet will not be filtered

Assessment: Not true. Upload filters will become an obligation for platforms that want to enter the market. The distinction between Internet and platforms is artificial. There is hardly any internet service without active user involvement. The spectrum of user generated content ranges from newspaper websites, blogs and social networking sites to online forums and cloud solutions.

+200 academics from over 25 research centres NEW Maxxis High Roller II TERRA EXO TR WT 29x2.5 tubeless Mountain tire

Claim: There is no problem relating to freedom of expression

Assessment: Not true. (…) Article 13 motivates firms to use cheap upload filters which will block legitimate content. Complaint and redress mechanisms are insufficient to cope with this problem. Expressions such as permissible parodies will be affected.

+200 academics from over 25 research centres Open Letter

The world should be concerned about new proposals to introduce a system that would automatically filter information before it appears online. Through pre-filtering obligations or increased liability for user uploads, platforms would be forced to create costly, often biased systems to automatically review and filter out potential copyright violations on their sites. We already know that these systems are historically faulty and often lead to false positives.

Professor María Sefidari Huici Chair of the Wikimedia Foundation

(…) under the new Directive, activity that is core to Reddit, like sharing links to news articles, or the use of existing content for creative new purposes (r/photoshopbattles, anyone?) would suddenly become questionable under the law. (…) Protecting rights holders need not come at the cost of silencing European internet users.

Reddit NEW Maxxis High Roller II Tire 27.5x2.4 3C EXO

New 'Roadie' Design Garage Bike Turbo Trainer Hallway Floor Mat (180cm x 40cm)

What’s at Stake?

#1 Making Platform primarily liable leads to filtering, even when filtering is not mentioned

Article 17’s [ex Art. 13] various versions creates a system whereby platforms face an increased (direct) liability for the content uploaded by their users if it infringes copyright. As a result, these platforms are likely to overblock even legal content and use automated techniques to avoid being sued, which will mean users will no longer be able to share and experience the content they were used to find online.

Our Ability To Post Content On The Internet Will Be Limited By A Censorship Machine

Some of the content uploaded on the Internet infringes the copyright of rightholders (which are often not the content creators but intermediaries and investors such as recording or film studios) and content creators complain that due to the digital evolution, they make less money than they used to (the so-called ‘value gap’). This does not reflect the reality accurately, specifically in the case of the music industry that year after NEW Maxxis Ignitor 29 x 2.10 E XO Tubeless Ready Tire announce that their incomes keep increasing. However, what they claim is that some platforms (YouTube, Vimeo… ) do not pay them enough when they stream copyrighted content: that is what they call the “value gap” (the gap between what rightsholders think would be fair as a compensation and what platforms pay them).

Article 17 [ex Art. 13] claims to address these problems but does so it in a way that hampers the way the Internet has been functioning so far by asking platforms to put in place costly and opaque solutions to pre-screen our content. This proposal would require intermediaries such as Facebook and YouTube to constantly police their platforms with censorship machines, often with no human element involved in the process. It will mean that you will no longer be able to upload or enjoy the same content as you used to, as automated blocking is likely to stop (legitimate) content of ever making it online. Analyses by EDRi of the European Commission and New Maxxis Ikon 27.5 x 2.20 Tire Folding 120tpi 3C Maxx Speed EXO Tubeless Ready proposals show the underlying threats in Article 17’s [ex Art. 13] logic.

And what’s worse: none of the versions of Article 17 [ex Art. 13] make life better for creators. Article 17 [ex Art. 13] actually makes New Maxxis Ikon 29 x 2.20 Tire Folding 20tpi 3C Maxx SpeedTubeless Ready of creators: only rightholders.

#2 This affects much more than YouTube and Facebook…which already comply with Article 17 [ex Art. 13]

The scope of application of Article 17 [ex Art. 13] is excessively broad and does not comprise any mechanism that constrains inappropriate or unreasonable claims by rightholders. To solve this, some of the proposed version include carve-outs for specific platforms in a more or less defined manner (for example for online encyclopediae like Wikipedia) but this approach means that only those platforms that are known and valued today get a ‘pass’ from the censorship machine.

New Censorship Machines Should Not Be ‘Encouraged’ And Existing Ones Should Have User Safeguards

The measures required by Article 17 [ex Art. 13] to avoid liability will be expensive to implement and will thus make it harder for European start-ups to grow and compete with big US platforms that already have these filters in place (such as YouTube with ContentID).

Moreover, where most of the ‘complaints’ seem to come from the music and film industry, Article 17 [ex Art. 13] applies to all types of platforms and all types of content, including text or software code, or music sheets, architect blueprints, etc.

As organisations such as Github and NEW Maxxis Ikon 3C TR 29x2.35 tubeless Mountain tire raised their voice, carve-outs have been written to try and avoid them becoming collateral damage of Article 17 [ex Art. 13]. But what about the companies that have not raised their voice or not been heard (e.g. WordPress, AirBnB)? What about the platforms that do not exist yet but could bring the same benefit to society in the future as Wikipedia does currently? The carve outs show the collateral damage is real. The extent however is currently unfathomable, as shown by an infographic by trade association EDIMA (note: some versions of the text of Article 17 [ex Art. 13] include partial carve-outs for code sharing platforms, online encyclopedia, online retail platforms and (B2C) cloud services but these are not without loopholes).

New Carbon Fiber Bike cycling Drop Mountain Bicycle Racing Drop Handlebars bar nsjkfy633-Handlebars

The copyright rules in the European Union are extremely complex and nuanced, as evidenced by a solid body of case law from the highest European court, the Court of Justice of the European Union. Many of the handling we currently do on social media rely on exceptions to copyright (such as parody or quotation) which are not identifiable by algorithms as they require ‘context’ (is this funny? Are you acting in a non-commercial manner? Did you use this for the purpose of criticism) and are not implemented in the same manner in each EU Member State.

Algorithms and Filters Have a Proven New Maxxis Minion DHF 26 x 2.50 Tire Folding 60tpi Single Compound EXO at Being Bad At Nuance

Creativity and free speech will be harmed by Article 13 because algorithms New Maxxis Minion DHF 29 x 2.50 Tire Folding 60tpi Dual Compound EXO Tubeless to tell the difference between infringement and the legal use of copyrighted material vital to research, commentary, parodies and more. This is far too high a cost for enforcing copyright.

No filter can possibly review every form of content covered by the proposal including text, audio, video, images and software. Article 13’s mandate is technically infeasible and it is absurd to expect courts in 27 EU Member States to be constantly working out what the “best” filters might be.

Moreover, it is a bad idea to make Internet companies responsible for enforcing copyright law. To ensure compliance and avoid penalties, platforms are sure to err on the side of caution and overblock. To make compliance easier, platforms will adjust their terms of service to be able to delete any content or account for any reason. That will leave victims of wrongful deletion with no right to complain – even if their content was perfectly legal.

Finally, the proposed censorship machines are a disproportionate and ineffective ‘solution’ to the problem: this has been highlighted by the highest European Court, the Court of Justice of the European Union, in a decision called SABAM v Netlog (CJEU C-360/10), which ruled that social networks and other web hosting providers cannot be required to monitor and filter activities that occur on their sites to prevent copyright infringement. This would be a breach of freedom of expression and of privacy.

What’s been agreed?

The compromise reached between the EU institutions represents the worst version of all the reform drafts presented so far. Various key flaws can be identified, amongst which the fact that:

  • Platforms are directly liable: Article 17 [ex Art. 13]makes platforms directly liable for user uploaded content, which implies that platform will filter to the max only to make sure they are on the safe side.
  • Fundamental rights are impacted: Article 17 [ex Art. 13] will seriously affect our fundamental rights, especially our freedom of expression and right to information.
  • The real burden is on citizens: Individuals using online services will be caught in the middle of a fight between platforms and rightsholders. Legal content could be increasingly taken down ‘just in case’, because platforms have to licence all content that can be uploaded on their platform, but rightholders do not have any obligation to negotiate with platforms.
  • User safeguards will be non-existent in practice: When legal content is removed, companies will likely block content based on their terms of service and not based on Article 17 [ex Art. 13]. In effect, the complaints from individuals about wrongly removed content will not work.

What’s next?

On 26 March 2019, all 750 Members of the European Parliament (MEPs) adopted an EU copyright reform that forces upload filters onto the Internet, as Article 17 (ex Art. 13) was not deleted. The next step is the final approval of the Council (= EU Member States) at the Ministerial level, which is expected in April. NEW Maxxis Minion DHF 3C EXO TR WT 26x2.5 tubeless Downhill tire for more information about how your MEPs voted on 26 March.

New RST Capa 26 Suspension Fork - Threaded Steerer
New School BMX Flatland - 165MM Primo Hollowbite Cranks - Flatland (Pr1mo) 22mm
New Schwalbe Racing Ralph Liteskin Tire 29 x 2.25 EVO
New Selle San Marco Aspide Saddle White
15 April 2019

NEW Maxxis Minion DHF Tire 27.5 x 2.30 Folding 60tpi 3C EXO Tubeless Ready

On 15 April EU Member States are likely to approve the text: The next step is the final approval of the Council (= EU Member States) at the Ministerial level, which will happen at the Agriculture and Fisheries Council meeting.
NEW She Safari RHODE gold VEST Shooting boyt shotgun Trap Skeet Leather Women XS 26 March 2019

NEW Maxxis Minion DHR II 3C EXO TR 26x2.4 tubeless Mountain tire

The European Parliament adopted Article 17 [ex Art. 13]: On 26 March 2019, the Members of the European Parliament (MEPs) adopted an EU copyright reform that forces upload filters onto the Internet.
New Carbon Fiber Bike cycling Drop Mountain Bicycle Racing Drop Handlebars bar nsjkfy633-Handlebars

NEW Shimano 7 8-Speed Chain Pins Box of 50
NEW Shimano CS-6500 Ultegra Bicycle Cassette (9-Speed, 12 25T)

New Carbon Fiber Bike cycling Drop Mountain Bicycle Racing Drop Handlebars bar nsjkfy633-Handlebars

NEW Specialized S-WORKS SHIV + - 37.5mm Offset Carbon Seat Post Tri Triathlon
New SRAM AeroGlide Red eTap 11 Speed Ceramic Rear Derailleur Pulley Wheel Set